Approve the storyboard to lock shot order, framing and the number of setups; approve style frames to lock how finished frames will look; approve the animatic to lock timing against the voiceover and music; approve previs to lock camera moves, lenses and what has to be built on set or in 3D. Each approval fixes a decision that costs more to change at every later stage, so sign them off in that order and reopen one only on purpose.
An animatic is not a fancier storyboard, and a style frame is not a better-looking board. Each artifact answers a different question, firms up different lines of the production bid, and carries different risks when it is made with AI tools. This article defines each one by what it locks, maps the approvals to the bid and the schedule, explains the limits of AI boards and AI previs, and ends with how many review rounds to budget. Rules and tool terms are as of November 2026.
What each artifact locks, at a glance
Each development artifact exists to settle one kind of decision before money is spent on the next stage. Read the table by the “locks” column: that is what you are agreeing to when you sign off.
- Storyboard: a sequence of drawn frames, one or more per shot, with the action, the dialogue or voiceover, and camera notes.
- Style frame: a single still made to finished quality, showing exactly how a frame of the final spot will look.
- Animatic: the storyboard frames edited to time against a scratch voiceover and temporary music, often with simple movement.
- Boardomatic: the simplest animatic, made of the boards themselves with cuts and basic pans or zooms.
- Previs: short for previsualization, a rough moving version of a shot, usually built in simple 3D, used to plan camera, lens, timing and builds.
| Artifact | Answers | Locks | Leaves open | Who signs off |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Storyboard | What happens, in what order, from where | Shot list, framing, setups, cast on camera, props and sets | Exact timing, the finished look, lenses | Brand lead, agency creative, claims reviewer |
| Style frames | What the finished picture looks like | Palette, line, materials, lighting, type, how layers combine | Motion, timing, shot order | Brand lead, brand design owner |
| Animatic | How long everything takes | Shot durations, read pace, music edit points, super and end card timing | The look, camera details | Brand lead, agency creative, legal for supers |
| Previs | How the camera and the build work | Camera paths, lenses, speeds, set and CG builds, plate needs | Performance, final look | Director, producer, 3D or VFX lead, brand for key moves |
Not every spot needs all four. A simple live-action spot may go from boards to an animatic and straight to the shoot. A 2D animated spot may skip previs entirely. A mixed-media spot with 3D product shots and composites usually needs all of them, because each blended shot depends on decisions from every column.
Storyboard: shot order, framing and the number of setups
Approving the storyboard locks what happens in each shot, in what order and from roughly where the camera sees it. That approval decides the number of setups, locations, sets and on-camera performers, which is most of what a live-action bid is built from.
What a board contains
A working board has a frame for each shot, or several for a shot with a camera move, a shot number, the action in a sentence, the voiceover or dialogue under it, and notes on camera movement and transitions. For a mixed-media spot it should also say which medium each shot uses: live action, 2D animation, 3D or a composite. Presentation boards add polish for internal selling; thumbnail boards are rough and fast. Both can lock the same decisions.
What the approval locks
- The shot list and its order. Every later document counts from it.
- Framing. Wide, medium or close, and the angle on the product.
- Setups. Each change of camera position or lighting is time on the shoot day.
- Locations, sets and props. What has to be found, built, bought or rented.
- Who is on camera. The number of performers, which drives talent costs and usage.
- Where mandatories go. The logo, legal lines and product name need a place in the frames.
Boards for more than one aspect ratio
If the campaign runs in vertical and square placements as well as 16:9, the board has to show it. A filmed frame can only be cropped, and the default example in the aspect ratio crop calculator shows a 3,840 x 2,160 source keeping 32% of its frame for a 9:16 crop. A product placed at the edge of a wide board falls out of the vertical version.
Draw the key frames with the tallest crop marked, or draw separate frames for shots that will be recomposed for vertical. Then the sign-off covers framing for every ratio in the deliverable matrix, not only the widescreen one, and the shoot plan knows what has to stay inside the 9:16 area.
What it does to the bid
Most live-action cost follows from the board. The AICP Bid Form (2023 update) has sections for prep and shoot crew (both list a storyboard artist as a line), location expenses, props and wardrobe, studio costs with build, pre-light, shoot and strike days, art department labor and expenses, equipment rental and talent. A bidder reads the board to count setups and days, so a bid on unapproved boards is a bid on a guess.
What it does under the union contract
When union performers are cast, the board can also change what counts as one commercial. The 2025 SAG-AFTRA Commercials Contract Memorandum of Agreement lets a producer create shorter, longer and same-length versions without triggering a new commercial, provided performers shoot a single script or storyboard. It adds that “if performers are required to shoot separate scripts or storyboards, each script shall be considered a new commercial for session and use purposes.”
The same section says directorial changes on set relate to “the specific storyboard, script and fundamental concept”, and that payment for an alternate scene or line is required when it is reflected in a script or storyboard, or falls outside the spot’s fundamental concept. Writing scripts and boards for each version for recordkeeping and performer transparency does not, on its own, trigger an unpermitted edit, as long as performers shoot a single script or storyboard. Your payroll company and counsel apply these rules; the practical point is that one approved board per spot keeps the count clear.
What it leaves open
The board does not fix timing, the look or the lens. A frame drawn as a close-up can be shot on several lenses with very different results, and a shot drawn in one panel may run two seconds or six. Those decisions belong to the next three artifacts. Before sign-off, a board is cheap to change: a frame is redrawn. After the bid is awarded, a new shot can mean a new setup, a new location or a new day.
Style frames: the look of finished frames
Approving style frames locks how the finished spot looks: color, line, texture, materials, lighting, typography and how layers sit together. Every animated, rendered or composited frame is then built to match them, which is why they come before animation or rendering starts.
Style frames vs storyboard
The difference is the question each answers. A storyboard says what happens and where the camera is; a style frame says what one moment will look like when it is finished. Signing off a beautiful style frame does not sign off the shot order, and signing off a rough board does not sign off the look. Treat them as two separate approvals with two separate sets of notes.
What a set of style frames covers
Plan one style frame for each distinct look in the spot, not one per shot. In a mixed-media spot that usually means one for the drawn elements, one for the 3D product and one for each blended shot, where all the layers meet. For live action, the equivalent is a look reference in the treatment: lighting, color and wardrobe references that the director and cinematographer commit to.
What the approval locks
- Palette and contrast, including how brand colors render on screen.
- Line and texture for drawn elements: weight, edges, grain.
- Materials and lighting for 3D: finish, reflections, shadow softness.
- Typography: fonts, sizes, how supers sit on the picture.
- Layer relationships in composites: what passes in front of what, and how drawn and real elements share light.
Review style frames where they will be seen
Look at style frames at the size and on the kind of screen where the ad will run. Colors shift between a calibrated monitor, a phone and a television, and type that reads well on a desktop can vanish at phone size. Check the vertical version on a phone, the connected-TV version on a television, and the smallest legal line at its delivery size before signing off.
What a late change costs
Before animation starts, a style change repaints a still. After animation starts, it reworks every finished frame built to the old look. In 3D, a material change after the final render pass means rendering again. That is the reason to bring the brand’s design owner, the person who guards the color and type standards, into this approval and not only the marketing lead.
Animatic: timing against scratch voiceover and music
Approving the animatic locks time: how long each shot runs, how fast the voiceover reads, where the music changes and how long each super and the end card stay on screen. It is the first time the spot plays at its real length, and the cheapest place to find that a shot runs long or a line reads too fast.
Animatic vs boardomatic, and the other “-matics”
The terms describe how much movement is added to the boards:
- Boardomatic: the boards themselves, cut to time, with simple pans and zooms.
- Animatic: boards plus extra drawings or moving elements, so actions and camera moves read in motion.
- Photomatic: the same idea built from photographs or stock images.
- Ripomatic: cut from existing footage to show tone or pace. If that footage belongs to others, keep the ripomatic for internal review only.
All of them lock the same thing, timing. More movement makes timing easier to judge, especially for camera moves and animated transitions, but it costs more to make and to change.
What the approval locks
- Shot durations, to the frame, which become the edit’s starting point.
- The voiceover script and pace. A line that does not fit is cut here, not in the recording booth.
- Music edit points. Where beats, swells and silence fall.
- Super and legal line timing. Long enough to read, which legal reviewers should check here.
- The cutdown plan. Which shots survive in the 15-second and 6-second versions.
Timing the script before the animatic
Timing starts with the words. At 150 words per minute, a voiceover reads at 2.5 words per second, so the script timing calculator gives rough word budgets of 12 words for 6 seconds, 30 for 15 seconds, 60 for 30 seconds and 135 for 60 seconds. The animatic then tests those numbers against real pictures.
Example (fictional). The site’s example campaign plans an invented 30-second spot for the Orlenna Ridge Bottle; Orlenna is not a client and the figures are illustrations. Its voiceover is 42 words. At 150 words per minute that is 42 / 150 x 60 = 16.8 seconds of reading. With 6 seconds of music-only moments, the total is 22.8 seconds, leaving 30 minus 22.8 = 7.2 seconds for pauses and the end card.
The animatic cuts the 8 boards to these durations: shot 1, 4 seconds; shot 2, 3; shot 3, 5; shot 4, 5; shot 5, 3; shot 6, 4; shot 7, 3; shot 8, 3. They add up to 4 + 3 + 5 + 5 + 3 + 4 + 3 + 3 = 30 seconds. The review checks one thing above all: whether the 5 seconds given to the drawn chart in shot 3 (7 to 12 seconds) hold up against the voiceover before anyone animates the curve.
What to check in an animatic review
Watch it several times, once without sound and once with your eyes closed, and answer a short list of questions:
- Does the product appear early enough, and is it on screen long enough to recognize?
- Does the voiceover have room to breathe, or is every second filled?
- Can every super and legal line be read in the time it is on screen, by someone who did not write it?
- Does the end card hold long enough for the logo and the web address?
- Does the 15-second cut still make sense with the shots it keeps, and does the 6-second cut carry one clear idea?
Each “no” is cheaper to fix now, by moving a cut, than after animation or the shoot.
Temporary music is not a license
Temp music in an animatic is a placeholder. It licenses nothing, and teams that live with a famous temp track for weeks often find the real track hard to clear or to replace. Pick a temp track close to what the budget can license, and note the licensing route at the animatic stage. The rights and usage page explains how music rights are recorded.
When the animatic is the version that gets tested
The AICP Bidding Reference Guide (February 2026), listed on the AICP’s bidding resources page, suggests asking at the first call whether the creative has been sold through to the advertiser’s decision makers and whether it has gone or will go through testing. If audience testing is planned, the animatic is the earliest version that plays at length, so schedule the test before the production bid is awarded, not after.
Previs: camera moves, lenses and what has to be built
Approving previs locks how the camera moves, which lenses and speeds it uses, and what must be built on set or in 3D to make the shot work. It turns drawn intentions into measurements a crew, a rig operator and a 3D team can plan against.
What previs contains
A previs scene is a simple 3D version of the set or location, with stand-in figures and products, and a virtual camera set to real lens focal lengths. It plays at real speed so the director can test a move and the producer can see what it needs. Two related terms appear in bids: techvis, the technical data taken from previs (camera height, distance, lens, rig speed) for the crew, and postvis, rough composites made after the shoot with temporary 3D to guide the edit.
When a spot needs it
- Complex or repeated camera moves, such as a motion-control move that must match across passes.
- Mixed-media shots, where a live plate has to leave room for a 3D product or drawn element.
- 3D product shots, where the previs becomes the layout for the final render.
- Large builds or rigs, where a set piece or a crane has to be sized before it is ordered.
A simple talking shot or a 2D animated spot rarely needs previs. Spend it where a wrong guess would cost a shoot day or a render pass.
What the approval locks
- Camera paths and speeds, frame by frame for the planned move.
- Lenses, which decide how much of the set must exist and how the product looks.
- Builds: set dimensions, platforms, green screen size, 3D environments.
- Plate requirements for composites: where the stand-in goes, what the clean pass covers.
- Equipment and shoot order: cranes, sliders, motion control, and which shots are grouped.
What it does to the bid
Previs firms up the equipment rental and studio build lines on the AICP Bid Form, and gives the 3D or VFX bid a real shot list with frame counts. Without it, bidders either pad for the worst case or exclude the risk and come back later with a change order.
Example (fictional). In the Orlenna plan, previs is used for shot 1, the ridge at dawn (0 to 4 seconds, 96 frames at 24 fps), made with AI-assisted tools so the shoot plan knows the angle and the light it needs. It is also the layout for shot 5 (17 to 20 seconds), where the real hand must leave room for the 3D bottle and the drawn line. Both previs clips are planning documents and never appear in the delivered spot.
AI-assisted boards, boardomatics and previs: speed and limits
AI image and video tools can produce board frames, boardomatics and rough previs clips quickly, which is useful for exploring options. Before any of it is signed off, check four limits: generated frames look finished while hiding open decisions, tool terms may license your uploads for training, generated images are not protected by copyright on their own, and prompts must not use a real person’s likeness without consent.
Finished-looking frames hide open decisions
A generated frame shows a lens, a light, a wardrobe, a cast and a product in full detail, even though nobody decided any of them. Approvers react to that polish and sign off things the board was never meant to settle. Generated frames also get products wrong (an extra button, a misspelled logo, the wrong cap), and AI previs clips can show camera moves no real rig can make.
Three habits keep the approval honest:
- Label every AI-assisted frame in the board and in the provenance log, with the tool category and the reviewer.
- State what the approval covers. For example: “Approving shot order, framing and setups only; casting, wardrobe, product detail and lighting are not approved.”
- Redraw or replace product frames with ones built from the real product or its drawings before the board goes to bidders.
AI previs clips are not measured previs
A generated video clip can suggest mood, blocking and pace, but it contains no measured camera path, lens or set dimension. Nothing in it tells a rig operator how high the camera is, or a 3D artist where the plate’s horizon sits. Traditional 3D previs can export that data as techvis, which is why it remains the tool for shots that a rig, a plate or a render must match. Use AI clips to choose between ideas, then build measured previs for the shots that need it.
Confidentiality: read the tool’s terms before uploading an unreleased product
Uploading a product that has not launched, its CAD, or an unannounced name to an AI tool shares it under that tool’s terms. Runway’s Terms of Use, last updated October 23, 2026, are one published example. They say the company does not claim ownership of your inputs or outputs and, subject to compliance with the agreement, does not restrict commercial use of outputs. They also say inputs and outputs “may be used by the Company to train and improve its AI models”, and grant the company a non-exclusive, irrevocable, perpetual, worldwide license to use them for those purposes.
The same page points enterprise customers to separate Runway Enterprise Services Terms, so the plan you are on matters. The AICP guide’s first-call questions include whether a mutual NDA has been provided for the project, and uploading NDA-protected material to a service whose terms allow training on it may conflict with that NDA; counsel decides. Check the terms of the exact plan, and keep unreleased material out unless the brand agrees in writing. The AI-assisted production page describes where these tools fit, and the AI practices page holds the policy.
Copyright: generated board frames are not protected on their own
The U.S. Copyright Office’s registration guidance, effective March 16, 2023, says copyright “can protect only material that is the product of human creativity”, and that AI-generated content that is more than de minimis should be excluded from a registration. Its Part 2 report on copyrightability, published January 2025, concludes that prompts alone do not provide sufficient control, while human expression perceptible in an output and creative “selection, coordination, or arrangement” or modification remain protectable.
A storyboard looks a lot like the work in the Office’s Zarya of the Dawn decision (February 21, 2023): an 18-page comic book of images and text. The Office found the author owned the text and the selection, coordination and arrangement of the text and images, but that the images generated with Midjourney “are not the product of human authorship”. It said it would cancel the original certificate and issue a new one covering only the material she created. By the same reasoning, an inference for counsel to confirm, a board of generated frames with written action and voiceover lines is likely in a similar position: the words and the arrangement may be protected, the generated frames on their own are not.
Two passages of the Part 2 report keep this in proportion. Using AI as a brainstorming aid, “referencing, but not incorporating, the output”, should not affect the copyrightability of the resulting human-authored work. And “a film that includes AI-generated special effects or background artwork is copyrightable, even if the AI effects and artwork separately are not.” The finished commercial is a different work from its boards. If the brand wants to own and register the boards or key designs themselves, have those frames drawn by people. Counsel decides any registration question.
Disclosure: planning tools do not need platform labels, the final ad might
Platform labels apply to what viewers see. YouTube’s GenAI disclosure page lists “production assistance, like using generative AI tools to create or improve a video outline, script, thumbnail, title, or infographic” and “idea generation” among the uses that do not need disclosure. An AI boardomatic or previs clip used only for planning therefore does not trigger a label by itself. If AI-generated realistic material ends up in the delivered spot, the rule for that material applies, as covered in the guide to AI ad disclosure labels.
Likeness: do not prompt with real people
Casting by prompt is a likeness question. The 2025 SAG-AFTRA MOA requires a producer who creates a synthetic performer using an identified performer’s name, image, photograph or recording in the prompt to get that performer’s consent and bargain for payment. Outside the union contract, using a real person’s face or name in a board raises the same consent question, so describe types, not people. The MOA’s definition of generative AI excludes “traditional AI” technologies such as CGI and VFX already used in pre-visualization and other stages, so conventional 3D previs is not what that section addresses.
How approvals map to the bid and the schedule
Each approval firms up specific lines of the bid and specific dates in the schedule. Approving out of order, such as asking for a final bid before boards are signed off, turns those lines into guesses and invites change orders later.
| Approval | Bid lines it firms up | Schedule items it fixes | Still estimated after it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Treatment and blend map | Which media each shot uses, and the overall split | The production plan’s stages and review dates | Everything below |
| Storyboard | Crew, locations, props, studio days, art department, talent count | Scouting, casting, shoot days | Look, timing, lenses |
| Style frames | Animation and 3D look development, art department look | Start of animation and 3D look development | Timing, camera details |
| Animatic | Edit, voiceover session, music length and edit points, cutdowns | Voiceover record, music license, edit schedule | Camera paths, builds |
| Previs | Equipment rental, build days, 3D and VFX shot list with frame counts | Shoot order, rig days, render schedule | Performance, final look |
The how we work page lists the same stages in order, and the commercial production timeline guide covers how long each stage usually needs. The figure shows where the approvals fall in one fictional 8-week plan.
Read the figure from the shoot backward. Every approval lands before week 4, because the shoot day and the 3D model both depend on boards, style frames and previs being final. An approval that slips past week 3 does not only move itself: it moves the shoot, the render schedule and every stage after them.
How many approval rounds to budget
Budget a set number of review rounds per artifact, write them into the schedule with dates, and collect one consolidated set of notes per round from everyone who signs off. The later the artifact, the more each extra round costs, so spend rounds early.
Rules that keep rounds from multiplying
- Name every approver before round one. Including legal or claims review, the brand design owner and whoever signs the final cut. A new voice at round three restarts the discussion.
- Consolidate notes. One document per round, with conflicts resolved on the brand side before it is sent.
- Give each round a scope. Round one is for structure; round two is for refinement. A structural change in round two is a new round.
- Write down what is approved. A short sign-off note naming what is locked, and what is not, prevents later disputes about whether a change is a revision or a new request.
- Bring legal in at the board. Claims, supers and mandatories are cheapest to fix in drawings.
What each reviewer checks
Rounds go faster when each approver knows which question is theirs. A useful split:
| Reviewer | Checks at boards | Checks at style frames and animatic |
|---|---|---|
| Brand or marketing lead | The message, the product’s role, the order of ideas | That the spot still says one thing in its length |
| Brand design owner | Logo placement and product angles | Color, type, materials and the end card |
| Legal or claims reviewer | Claims, demonstrations, mandatories | Super wording, reading time, disclosures |
| Media or placement owner | Framing for every ratio in the plan | Cutdown structure and platform safe zones |
| Producer | Setups, locations, builds and talent count | Durations that the schedule and budget can carry |
Anyone not on the list can comment, but their notes go through one of these people. That keeps each round to one consolidated document.
What a change costs at each stage
| When the change arrives | What has to be redone |
|---|---|
| During the script | Rewrite lines |
| After storyboard sign-off | Redraw frames, re-count setups, possibly re-bid |
| After style frame sign-off | Repaint stills; re-check the boards against the new look |
| After animatic sign-off | Re-edit timing; re-time animation and coverage plans |
| After previs sign-off | Re-block camera moves; re-check rigs, builds and plates |
| After the shoot | Reshoot, or fix in compositing if the plate allows |
| After animation | Re-animate the affected seconds |
| After the final render | Render the affected frames again, then re-composite |
The table is the argument for front-loading review. In the example schedule, a note that costs a redrawn frame in week 2 can cost a reshoot once the week 4 shoot is done.
Example (fictional). The Orlenna plan has 2 weeks of development (weeks 2 and 3), or 2 x 5 = 10 working days. It budgets 2 rounds each for the script, the storyboard, the style frames and the animatic, and 1 round for previs: 2 + 2 + 2 + 2 + 1 = 9 review points. Nine review points in 10 working days only work if notes come back within 1 working day and if some artifacts run in parallel: the style frames are made while the boards are reviewed, and previs is built while the animatic is cut.
If the brand needs 2 working days to return notes, the same 9 review points no longer fit, and the choice is to drop rounds, accept a later shoot, or move previs into week 4 alongside the shoot preparation. Deciding that before development starts is cheaper than discovering it in week 3.
How to decide the number for your spot
Add rounds where the risk is: a new brand look needs more style frame rounds; a dense claim needs more animatic rounds for super timing; a complex move needs a second previs round. Cut rounds where the artifact is routine. Then check the total against the calendar, as in the example, before anyone starts drawing.
Checklist: what to approve, in order
Sign off each artifact for the decision it locks, in this order, and write down what each sign-off covers. The production glossary defines the terms if your team uses different names.
- Treatment and blend map. Which shots are filmed, animated, rendered or blended, and why.
- Script with a timed read. Words counted against the length, before boards are drawn.
- Storyboard. Shot order, framing, setups, cast on camera, mandatories placed. Legal and claims review here.
- Style frames. One per distinct look, signed off by the brand’s design owner as well as the marketing lead.
- Animatic. Durations, read pace, music edit points, super timing, cutdown plan. Test it if testing is planned.
- Previs, where needed. Camera paths, lenses, builds and plate requirements for complex, mixed-media and 3D shots.
- AI-assisted material. Every AI frame labeled, unreleased material kept out of tools whose terms allow training, no real person’s likeness without consent, and a note of which frames people drew.
- The bid and schedule. Requested only after the artifacts they depend on are signed off.
The creative development service page describes how these documents are produced, and the example campaign shows them inside one fictional plan. If you have a script or boards ready, you can send a brief with them, and the production plan that comes back shows which approvals your spot needs.
