A video production brief gets comparable quotes when it settles, before anyone bids, the decisions that set cost and schedule: where each ad will run, the full deliverable matrix (lengths, aspect ratios, languages and versions), how long and where the ads may be used, whether talent is union or non-union, what may be AI-assisted and how it will be disclosed, whether captions are delivered, which assets already exist, the deadline, a budget range and who approves each stage. Send the same brief to every bidder and ask each to price it in the same structure, ideally the sections of the AICP Bid Form, and the estimates can be read line by line.
Objective, audience and message still belong in the brief. They tell a director what the spot has to do. They do not tell a producer how many shoot days, render hours, edit versions or usage cycles to price, and that is where two bids for the same idea drift apart.
This guide explains how to write a video production brief field by field, says why each field changes a quote, and shows where each one lands on the AICP Bid Form. It ends with a worked example and a checklist you can use with the creative brief worksheet.
Why two quotes for the same idea come back so different
Two quotes differ when each bidder fills the gaps in a brief with its own assumptions. If the brief does not say how many versions, one producer prices four files and another prices twenty-four, and both are right about a brief that never said.
A production brief, for this guide, is the document a buyer sends to production companies describing what to make and under which constraints, so that each company can propose a plan and price it. Agencies sometimes call it the bid package or the bid specs. It is different from an internal creative brief, which records the insight and the message; many in-house teams combine the two, which is fine as long as the production fields are there.
The Association of Independent Commercial Producers (AICP), a US trade association of commercial production and post companies, publishes the questions its members ask at the first call. Its Bidding Reference Guide (February 2026) asks, among other things:
- What is the proposed budget, and is it “all in”? Does it include social elements, stills and behind-the-scenes material? Post, talent, VFX, music and finish?
- Is the project a single bid or a multi-bid, and who else is bidding?
- Is the talent SAG or non-union?
- Is there a proposed timeline, and when is the work expected to air?
- Is the project firm bid, cost-plus or a blend?
- What are the deliverables, and do they match the length of the creative? The guide’s own example is a deliverable of :15 for creative written as a :60 or :90.
- What is the shoot aspect ratio, and will deliverables vary, such as a vertical format for social?
- Are stock footage or other licensed materials needed, and are they in the budget?
Every question on that list is one a brief can answer before it is asked. When it does, each bidder starts from the same facts and the differences between bids are differences in approach, which is what you are trying to compare.
The same association’s Suggested Best Practices for bidding (2026) puts the fairness rule plainly: agencies should be “supplying all bidders with the same job-scope information and the opportunity to bid.” It also notes that multi-bid jobs are typically limited to three directors or companies, and that if the buyer wants more, the number of bidders should be disclosed before bidding starts. A brief written once and sent to all bidders on the same day is the practical way to meet that rule.
Start with where the ads will run
Placement comes first because it decides the lengths, the aspect ratios, the file specs and sometimes what the ad is allowed to contain. Name every placement you intend to buy, not the channels you might use one day.
Google’s own rules show how much a placement decides. In a Google Ads Video reach campaign set to non-skippable reach, Google Ads Help says the ad format is determined by the video’s duration, as of November 2026:
- Bumper ads: videos up to 6 seconds long.
- Standard non-skippable: videos between 7 and 15 seconds long.
- 30-second non-skippable (CTV): videos 16 to 30 seconds long, shown on connected TV. Video assets must be horizontal; square or vertical assets will not be able to run.
That one rule has three consequences for a brief. A 30-second spot that will run on connected TV through this campaign type must exist as a horizontal file. A 20-second edit is not a standard non-skippable ad at all; it falls in the CTV band. And a vertical cut of the same spot is a separate deliverable for other placements, not a substitute.
Google’s About video ad formats page adds the maximum lengths by format: no maximum for skippable in-stream (under 3 minutes recommended), 15 to 60 seconds for non-skippable in-stream depending on the campaign subtype, 6 seconds for bumpers (with a 5-second minimum) and under 60 seconds recommended for Shorts ads.
Two Google settings also belong in a brief. The Video reach help page says “video enhancements” use Google AI to create additional versions of your videos in a vertical 9:16 ratio, that the feature is on by default for new campaigns, and that you opt out by unticking “Get vertical versions of your videos”. If your brand guidelines require a person to review every version before it runs, the brief should say so and the media buyer should know to opt out. The same page offers an optional AI label setting when you create the ad, which belongs with the AI decisions later in this guide.
Write placements as a short table in the brief: platform, placement, buying type (skippable, non-skippable, in-feed), lengths, aspect ratios and whether people are likely to watch with sound off. For broadcast and CTV publishers, attach each publisher’s spec sheet or say who will supply it.
Turn lengths, ratios and languages into a deliverable matrix
A deliverable matrix is the list of every finished file the job must produce: each concept multiplied by each length, aspect ratio, language and version. It is the single biggest driver of edit, finishing and quality-check time, and briefs that skip it get the widest spread of bids.
The AICP reference guide asks whether “all the deliverables have the same aspect ratio or format, or will it vary (such as a ‘vertical’ format for social elements)”. The matrix answers that question in full, before the first call.
Example (fictional). Orlenna is an invented Colorado bottle brand used across this site; it is not a client, and every figure here is an illustration. The Ridge Bottle launch needs 3 lengths (30, 15 and 6 seconds) x 4 aspect ratios (16:9, 9:16, 1:1 and 4:5) x 2 languages (English and Spanish) x 1 call to action = 24 deliverables.
At an assumed 45 minutes of edit and 10 minutes of quality check per version, the time is 24 x 45 = 1,080 minutes (18.0 hours) of edit plus 24 x 10 = 240 minutes (4.0 hours) of checking, or 22.0 hours in total: 2.8 eight-hour days.
Suppose the brand later adds a third language. The matrix becomes 3 x 4 x 3 x 1 = 36 deliverables and 36 x 55 = 1,980 minutes, or 33.0 hours. If it instead adds a second call to action to the original matrix, the count is 3 x 4 x 2 x 2 = 48 deliverables and 44.0 hours. One added dimension multiplies the whole matrix.
You can run your own numbers in the versioning matrix calculator. The point for the brief is that the matrix should arrive with the request, not be discovered after the bid is awarded.
The matrix also changes the shoot. If vertical versions are cut from a 16:9 master, very little of the frame survives. The aspect ratio crop calculator shows that a 9:16 crop from a 3840 x 2160 frame is 1,215 x 2,160 pixels, 32% of the original. A brief that lists 9:16 tells the director to compose with the product and any on-screen text inside that central strip, or to shoot separate vertical setups, and the bids will price whichever approach each company proposes.
Three habits keep the matrix honest:
- Cut it to the placements you will buy. A 1:1 version for a placement you will not fund is a cost with no audience.
- Separate native from cutdown. Say whether the 15-second and 6-second versions can be edited from the 30-second spot or need their own shots, scripts or animation. Bumpers in particular often need a different structure.
- Name the files in the brief. A naming convention (campaign, length, ratio, language, version) lets you check delivery against the brief at the end. The deliverables page shows the handover list this produces.
Say how long, where and in which media the ads will run
Usage is how long, where and in which media the finished ads may run. It changes the price of talent, music, stock footage and sometimes fonts, so a brief without it forces each bidder to guess, and they will guess differently.
Talent is the clearest case. The 2016 SAG-AFTRA Commercials Contract text (the Joint Policy Committee’s copy; later agreements amend it) states the principle directly: “Compensation to principal performers in commercials is based both on the services which the principal performer renders in the production of such commercials and on the use which is made of the finished commercial.” Under the union contracts, use fees are paid by medium and by cycle; under a non-union contract, the buyout fee is whatever the contract says it buys. Either way, the producer needs your media plan to price it. The union and non-union choice is covered in our guide to union or non-union talent.
Music has two layers. The Copyright Office’s Circular 56A explains that sound recordings and musical compositions “are considered two separate works for copyright purposes.” A commercial recording therefore has two rights holders to clear, the owner of the composition and the owner of the recording, while a production library track or an original score is licensed differently. The brief does not need to choose the route, but it must say where and for how long the music will play, or the music line cannot be priced.
Write usage as one line per group of deliverables:
| Deliverables | Media | Territory | Term | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30 s and 15 s, 16:9 | Connected TV, online video | United States | 12 months from first use | No broadcast this year |
| 15 s and 6 s, 9:16, 1:1, 4:5 | Paid social, YouTube | United States | 12 months from first use | Organic posting on brand channels included |
| Stills from 3D renders | Product page, retail listings | Worldwide | Perpetual, if available | Ask for a separate line |
That table uses invented terms to show the format. Your counsel and your media plan set the real ones. Also say whether a term starts at the shoot, the first air date or another event, because contracts count from different points, and list any exclusivity you will need (for example, that an on-camera performer may not appear in a competitor’s ad during the term).
Say, finally, whether the talent will be union or non-union, or ask bidders to recommend. The AICP reference guide asks “Is the talent SAG or non-union?” at the first call, because the answer changes the talent section, the payroll line and the schedule. If a celebrity, a real customer or an employee will appear, say so here too. The rights and usage page shows how these terms end up recorded in a rights sheet.
Write the AI and accessibility decisions into the brief
AI use and accessibility are decisions the buyer owns. If the brief is silent, bidders either price the conservative route or assume freedoms you did not intend to grant, and their numbers will not match.
AI policy
State which production steps may use AI-assisted tools, which may not, and who signs off. A workable policy names steps, not attitudes: concept frames and previs, cleanup of unwanted objects, rotoscoping for mattes, upscaling, and draft caption translations are steps a brand may allow with human review; synthetic people, cloned voices and digital replicas of real performers are steps many brands exclude or allow only with written consent.
Then say how disclosure will be handled, because some platforms require it. YouTube Help requires disclosure of realistic AI-generated or altered content that makes a real person appear to say or do something they did not do, alters footage of a real event or place, generates a realistic scene that did not occur, or creates music that is the main focus of the video. Its examples of content that does not need disclosure include unrealistic content, color adjustment and beauty filters, and production assistance such as using generative AI to draft an outline or script. In Google Ads, the Video reach setup includes an optional AI label setting for each video ad, per the help page cited above. Other platforms have their own rules; the brief should say who checks them.
If union performers are involved, the contract terms reach AI too. The Joint Policy Committee’s overview of the 2025 Commercials Contracts lists a 48-hour notice before using or creating a digital replica, consent through a Digital Replica Rider or separate signed writing, and 1.5 scale session fees when a replica generates a performance a performer would otherwise have given. A bidder cannot price that without knowing whether you intend it. Ask bidders to name the tool category for each AI-assisted step and to state whether your material will be kept out of any model training; Blendpipe’s own commitments on these points are set out on its AI practices page.
Captions and accessibility
Captions are a brief decision, not an automatic legal requirement for most spots. The FCC’s closed captioning rule, 47 CFR 79.1, defines video programming in paragraph (a)(10) to include “advertisements of more than five minutes in duration” but not “advertisements of five minutes’ duration or less.” A 30-second commercial falls outside that definition. Other obligations, a network’s delivery specification or your own accessibility policy may still call for captions, so the brief should say what you want and your counsel decides what you need.
The choice affects cost in concrete ways:
- Closed captions (a sidecar file such as SRT or WebVTT, or an embedded track) add a caption file per language and length but no extra video versions.
- Open captions (burned into the picture) add a video version for every language, which multiplies the matrix.
- Broadcast captions follow the delivery spec. The AICP file deliverable specification (February 2018) treats closed captioning as optional and, where supplied, as an embedded QuickTime caption track at 29.97 fps, noting that 23.98 fps is not supported.
- Audio description needs script time and a separate mix, so say whether you want it.
List what you already have, and what it is licensed for
Existing assets can remove whole sections of a budget, but only if the brief says what they are and what they are licensed for. A product CAD file can replace a tabletop shoot; last year’s footage can supply establishing shots; a licensed track can save a music search. Each one can also carry restrictions that make it unusable.
List these in the brief, each with its owner and any license limits:
- Brand guidelines, logo files and brand fonts (with the font license, which may not cover video or redistribution to a studio).
- Product CAD or 3D files, and the date physical product samples will exist.
- Existing footage, photography and animation, with the talent and music usage still attached to them. Footage with an expired talent term cannot simply be recut into a new ad.
- Music already licensed for the brand, with its media, term and territory.
- Mandatory copy: legal lines, claims and their substantiation, required logos or partner marks.
- Approved voice talent, if the brand has a contracted voice.
The AICP reference guide asks whether “costs for any stock footage or licensed materials” are included in the budget or needed. Answering in the brief lets each bidder decide whether to reuse, license or create, and lets you compare those decisions directly.
The fictional example on the creative brief worksheet shows the short form: “Brand guide, product CAD files, last season’s trail footage.” The long form adds the license status of each item.
Set the deadline, the review rounds and who approves
The schedule in a bid depends on three things only the buyer knows: the date the first version must be live, how many review rounds each stage gets, and who signs off. Leave them out and bidders will either pad the calendar or promise one they cannot keep.
Give dates, not adjectives. “ASAP” and “early Q2” cannot be scheduled. A first-live date, plus any fixed event such as a trade show or a retail reset, can be scheduled backward. The AICP guide asks “When is this expected to air?” and whether anything could shift the dates, such as a celebrity’s availability; answer both.
Define review rounds per stage. A typical sequence for a mixed-media spot is script, storyboards or animatic, style frames for animated and 3D looks, the offline edit, the finished master, and the version set. For each, say how many rounds you expect and how many business days your team needs to return notes. Our guide to commercial production timelines shows how those windows add up to the calendar.
Name the approvers. Every stage should have one person who signs off, plus a legal or claims reviewer who sees the script before the shoot and the master before delivery. The most expensive feedback is a new approver’s first note on a finished master.
Two practical additions help bidders plan:
- Blackout dates when your approvers are unavailable, such as a sales conference or a holiday week.
- Where the shoot can happen. If the brand prefers a region, a location type or a studio, say so. Permits and travel both affect the calendar.
Give a budget range and define what it includes
A budget range is not a negotiating weakness; it is information that lets each bidder shape a plan to the money available, so that three proposals arrive at roughly the same scale instead of one at a single shoot day and another at three.
The range only helps if everyone reads it the same way. The AICP best practices document says “Agencies should give clarity as to their definition of ‘all-in’ during the initial outreach”, and lists the usual questions: does it include social elements, stills and behind-the-scenes material; post, talent, VFX, music and finish; production insurance, or will the agency provide wrap-up insurance? Answer each one in the brief.
Then say how you want to buy. The AICP guide asks whether the project is “firm bid, cost-plus, or a blend”. A firm bid prices a defined scope at a fixed amount, so changes in scope become change orders. A cost-plus arrangement bills actual costs plus a fee, so the estimate is a forecast. Mixing the two across bidders makes the totals impossible to compare.
Three more lines prevent surprises:
- Treatments and pitch fees. The AICP best practices document says that if a production company decides to charge a pitch fee, the fee and its amount should be discussed and agreed in advance, and lists situations where companies may ask for one, such as more than three bidders or a script that has not been sold through to the advertiser. Say whether you will pay for treatments.
- Contingency. Ask bidders to show contingency as a separate line rather than spreading it across others. The AICP Bid Form has a “Contingencies (Not Billed)” block for exactly this.
- Payment terms. Deposit, milestone and final payment dates belong in the conversation before award, not after.
If you need a starting point for the range, the production budget worksheet lets you build one from your own rates; its example values are illustrations, not market prices.
Ask for bids in one structure: the AICP Bid Form
Asking every bidder to use one estimate structure is what turns three quotes into a comparison. For US commercials, the common structure is the AICP Bid Form, which AICP says was introduced in 1975 “to standardize bidding on commercials.” The current Excel version was updated in January 2023, with a PDF version alongside it.
The 2023 Bid Form summary page has these sections: A Prep Crew, B Shoot Crew, C Prep and Wrap Expenses, D Location Expenses, E Props, Wardrobe and Animals, F Studio Costs, G Art Department Labor, H Art Department Expenses, I Equipment Rental, J Media, K Miscellaneous Production Costs, a subtotal of A to K, then L Director’s Fees, M Talent, N Talent Expenses and O Other, followed by Insurance and the Production Fee. Below the total sit the P sections (additional production estimates broken out as expenses, labor, talent and a blank breakout) and the Contingencies (Not Billed) lines. The job information block above the summary asks for pre-production days, build and strike days, pre-light, stage days, location days, locations, and spot titles and lengths.
| Brief field | What it changes in the estimate | Where it shows on the AICP Bid Form |
|---|---|---|
| Placements and lengths | Number of setups, shoot days, edit time | Job information (spot titles and lengths, stage and location days); A, B, I |
| Deliverable matrix | Versions, finishing and quality-check hours | Post costs, often a separate bid or a P breakout; ask which |
| Aspect ratios and vertical needs | Framing, extra setups, extra camera or lens days | B Shoot Crew, I Equipment Rental, J Media |
| Usage, media and territory | Talent use fees, music and stock licenses | M Talent (day lines); ask bidders to state use fees in or out |
| Union or non-union talent | Session fees, payroll service, agency fees, fringes | M Talent (agency fees, payroll service lines), N Talent Expenses |
| Locations and permits | Location fees, permits, lane closures, travel | D Location Expenses |
| Existing assets (CAD, footage, music) | Fewer shoot or build days, license fees | F, G, H for builds; O Other or P breakouts for licenses |
| AI policy | Which steps are AI-assisted, review time, consent fees | O Other or a P breakout; ask bidders to list each step |
| Captions and accessibility | Caption files, open-caption versions, description mix | Post costs; ask for a separate line |
| Budget definition ("all in") | What is inside the total at all | Insurance, Production Fee, Contingencies (Not Billed) |
Two cautions make the form work for mixed-media and animated jobs.
First, the form is organized around a live-action shoot. Its job information names an editorial company, a VFX company and a music company next to the production company, so ask each bidder to say which of those costs its number includes. If animation, 3D or post are in the bid, ask for them as P breakouts or as a separate post estimate with the same line names from every bidder.
Second, the M Talent section lists day-based lines: on-camera principals, extras, hand models, voice over, fitting fees and audition fees, plus talent agency fees, talent payroll service and wardrobe allowance. It does not list use cycles. Ask every bidder to state whether talent use fees are included and for which media and term, or to leave them out and quote them separately.
Decide how many companies bid, and tell them
The number of bidders is part of the brief, because it changes how much work each company will put into its reply. The AICP best practices document describes two cases:
- Single bid. You approach one company. The document says the company should not accept projects that conflict with the single bid’s schedule, and that a buyer should not unilaterally require a treatment for a single-bid project; whether to provide one is a matter to negotiate.
- Multi-bid. Typically three directors or companies. The document asks buyers to disclose the number of bidders before bidding starts and, if names are not shared, to say whether any bidder is a rostered or preferred vendor, the incumbent on the campaign, an in-house unit of the agency or advertiser, a foreign production company, or a union or non-union production company.
It also recommends notifying bidders when one drops out or another is added, confirming the award in writing, and telling the companies that did not win so they can release the crew and dates they were holding.
One practice to avoid outright: asking for “check bids”, meaning bids submitted only to make a pre-chosen company look competitive. The AICP document describes complementary bidding as a form of bid rigging the US Department of Justice has warned about, and says that providing a check bid to satisfy a triple-bid requirement would not be best practice and might be deemed anticompetitive. If your procurement rules require three bids, make all three real by giving all three the same brief.
Ask for the same reply, not just the same form
The bid form carries the numbers. Ask each bidder to send the same supporting documents with it, so you can see what the numbers assume:
- A treatment or approach note, if you are asking for one, with its length stated in the brief.
- A schedule with the review points from your brief marked on it.
- A list of assumptions: shoot days, locations, talent count, number of revisions per stage, and what happens when a round is added.
- A list of exclusions: anything the bidder has priced out, such as talent use fees, media, or a second language.
- For each AI-assisted step, the tool category and the human review step.
On confidentiality, the AICP document recommends that buyers give each bidder a mutual NDA before bids are submitted, and notes that the production company’s ideas and project-specific financial information in the bid package do not transfer to the advertiser unless the job is awarded under a work-for-hire agreement. Put your NDA in the brief package so the question does not delay the replies.
When the estimates come back, our guide to reading a commercial production estimate explains how to compare them section by section.
A worked example: one request, briefed two ways
The difference between a thin brief and a complete one shows up as arithmetic before it shows up as price. This example uses the site’s fictional Orlenna launch and the per-version time assumptions from the versioning calculator.
Example (fictional). Orlenna is invented, and the bids are invented to show the mechanism; no real company’s pricing is implied.
The thin brief: “30-second launch video for the Ridge Bottle, for social and YouTube, outdoorsy and energetic. Budget to be discussed. Needed in eight weeks.”
Three bidders read it three ways. Bidder A prices one 16:9 master and three 15-second cutdowns: 4 files. Bidder B prices 3 lengths x 4 ratios: 12 files. Bidder C adds a Spanish version: 24 files. At 55 minutes of edit and quality check per file, that is 4 x 55 = 220 minutes (3.7 hours), 12 x 55 = 660 minutes (11.0 hours) and 24 x 55 = 1,320 minutes (22.0 hours) of versioning before anything else differs. Bidder A also assumes a non-union hiker with a one-year online buyout, Bidder B assumes union talent with use fees left out, and Bidder C assumes no on-camera talent at all. None of the three totals can be compared.
The complete brief answers the same request field by field:
- What: Orlenna Ridge Bottle, an insulated trail bottle. One message: hot at the trailhead, still hot at the top.
- Where it runs: paid social, online video, the product page and a trade show screen.
- Matrix: 30, 15 and 6 seconds; 16:9, 9:16, 1:1 and 4:5; English and Spanish; one call to action. 24 deliverables, each with a caption file.
- Usage: 12 months from first use. With a first use of March 1, 2027, the term ends February 29, 2028.
- Talent: one on-camera hiker; bidders to recommend union or non-union and price use for the stated media and term.
- AI policy: AI-assisted cleanup and rotoscoping allowed with frame-by-frame human review; no synthetic people or voices; disclosure checked per platform.
- Existing assets: brand guide, product CAD files, last season’s trail footage (talent and music rights to be confirmed).
- Approvals: named approver for each stage; legal reviewer sees the script and the master.
- Budget: a stated range, “all in” defined as production, post, talent session fees and music, excluding media.
- Format of reply: AICP Bid Form, with post, 3D and animation as P breakouts and talent use fees on a separate line.
Every bidder now prices 24 files, the same usage and the same AI rules. The bids can still differ, but now the differences mean something: one bidder proposes two shoot days, another proposes one day plus 3D for the product shots, and you can see which line carries the difference.
The complete brief is longer, but it is not harder to write. Most of its answers already exist somewhere in the marketing team; the brief just collects them before the bidders have to ask.
Before you send it: a brief checklist
A brief is ready to send when a producer who has never met you could price it without a call. Use this list to check, then send it to every bidder on the same day.
- Message and audience in two sentences each, with the one thing the viewer should remember.
- Placements with platform, placement, buying type, lengths and ratios, plus any publisher spec sheets.
- Deliverable matrix as a table, with a file naming convention and a note on which versions are native and which are cutdowns.
- Usage per group of deliverables: media, territory, term, start trigger and any exclusivity.
- Talent: on-camera, voice, real customers or employees; union, non-union or “please recommend”.
- AI policy: allowed steps, excluded steps, consent and disclosure owner.
- Captions and accessibility: closed, open or none; languages; audio description yes or no.
- Existing assets with their license status, and the date product samples will exist.
- Dates, rounds and approvers: first-live date, fixed events, review rounds per stage, review windows, named approvers and blackout dates.
- Budget range with “all in” defined, firm bid or cost-plus, pitch fee position, payment terms and the reply format (AICP Bid Form sections, with breakouts named).
The creative brief worksheet covers the core questions in a form you can export as a CSV; add the usage, AI and caption lines from this list to it. If you are deciding what kind of job you are briefing, from a single spot to a versioning project, the engagement types page describes what changes in each.
Blendpipe is a production studio in Colorado Springs that combines live action, animation, 3D and AI-assisted tools, and it answers a brief with a written production plan before production is committed; how we work shows the seven stages that follow. When your brief passes the checklist, you can send it through the contact page or to any producer you are considering, and the replies will be comparable.
