A video production cost estimate is the producer’s price for a defined plan, so you read it as a list of assumptions with money attached: what will be made, in how many versions, with which crew and talent, for which usage, and under which buying method. To compare two bids fairly, put them on the same deliverable matrix, the same talent and music usage, and the same treatment of contingency, production fee and insurance, then compare what remains line by line. Most commercial estimates in the US follow the AICP Bid Form, so its sections are the map for both steps.
This guide walks through that form, the terms the AICP’s own guidelines attach to it, the lines a mixed-media job adds, and a worked comparison of two fictional bids. Every dollar figure in it is an illustration, labeled as such. None is a Blendpipe price or a market rate.
What a production estimate is, and what it is not
An estimate is the producer’s answer to one specific plan. It is not a price list, and a total without its assumptions tells you very little.
People often search for how much a commercial costs to make. The honest answer is that the cost follows the plan: shoot days, locations, crew size, the number of animated seconds and rendered shots, the number of deliverables and the usage the talent and music must cover. Two bids for the same script can differ by tens of thousands of dollars because they price different plans, not because one producer is cheaper.
So read every estimate with three questions in mind:
- What plan does this price? Look for the shoot days, stage or location days, the spot titles and lengths, and the deliverables.
- How will it be billed? A fixed price for the scope, actual costs plus a fee, or a mix.
- What is left out? Exclusions and “client to provide” lines are often the biggest numbers on the page, because they are not on it.
If the estimate came back in a structure you cannot read, the problem usually started in the request. Our guide to writing a video production brief covers the inputs. This article covers the output.
How many bids, and what bidding costs the bidder
Bidding is unpaid work for the producer unless you agree otherwise, and the number of bidders changes how much care each bid gets. The AICP’s 2026 bidding best practices say multi-bid jobs “are typically limited to (3) directors/companies”, and that a buyer who wants more should disclose the number of bidders before bidding starts.
The same document discusses pitch fees, which some producers charge for treatments and bids. It says the fee and its amount should be agreed in advance, and lists situations where a producer may ask for one: more than three bidders, a script not yet sold through to the advertiser, a compressed deadline such as a weekend, or a scope that changes significantly during the pitch. If you plan to ask for detailed treatments from several companies, settle this question before the first call.
Ownership of the ideas in a bid is also addressed. The AICP’s live-action guidelines say ideas presented in a bid that were not in the client’s prior communications belong to the production company until the job is awarded and paid in full. The best practices document adds that a bid’s creative contributions do not transfer to the advertiser unless the project is awarded under a work for hire agreement. In practice, do not hand one bidder’s treatment to another.
The AICP Bid Form: the structure behind most commercial bids
The AICP Bid Form is the estimate template of the Association of Independent Commercial Producers, the US trade body for commercial production companies. The AICP says the original form was introduced in 1975 “to standardize bidding on commercials”, and it offers an Excel version updated in January 2023 alongside a PDF.
The 2023 PDF form opens with a job information block and a summary of estimated production costs. The detail pages follow, one per lettered section. The AICP’s live-action guidelines (April 2020) explain the logic: the form “was designed to organize the most commonly used live action cost items into groups A-K,” to which a single markup percentage is applied.
| Section | What it holds | What drives the number | What to check |
|---|---|---|---|
| A Prep Crew, B Shoot Crew | Producers, assistant directors, camera, grip, electric, art, hair and makeup, sound, safety, drivers | Days x rate per person, with overtime columns at 1.5 and 2.0 and fringes on labor | Prep days per role; crew size against the shot list |
| C Prep and Wrap Expenses, D Location Expenses | Travel, scouting, location fees, permits, lane closures, security, vehicles, meals | Number of locations and company moves | Permit lead times; whether a scout is included |
| E Props, Wardrobe and Animals | Props, wardrobe, picture vehicles, product prep and color correction | Number of setups and hero products | Who supplies the product, and how many samples |
| F Studio Costs, G and H Art Department | Stage rental for build, pre-light, shoot and strike days; set construction and dressing | Build days and set size | Whether build and strike days are counted |
| I Equipment Rental, J Media | Camera, lenses, lighting, grip, cranes, drives, transcoding, dailies | Shoot days and camera package | Whether data handling and transcodes for editorial are included |
| K Miscellaneous | Shipping, phones, special insurance, foreign production service | Job specifics | Anything large hiding in a small section |
| Production fee | The producer's fee on sections A to K | A percentage or a lump sum | Which sections it applies to |
| L Director's Fees | Director prep, travel, shoot and post days | Days and the director's rate | Post days for the director |
| M Talent, N Talent Expenses | Principals, extras, hand models, voiceover; agency, payroll, travel | Number of performers and the usage bought | Session fees versus usage; handling fees |
| O Other, P breakouts | Anything outside A to N; extra estimates broken out as expenses, labor and talent | Scope outside the core shoot | Where post, 3D, animation and versions sit |
| Insurance, Contingencies (Not Billed) | Production insurance; contingency shown but not billed unless used | Policy terms; risk | Whether contingency is separate or spread across lines |
Three structural details matter when you read a completed form:
- Labor carries overtime and fringes. The crew, art labor and talent pages each have overtime columns at 1.5 and 2.0 times the rate, plus a fringes line. A crew that looks cheap at the day rate can cost more once a long day is priced in.
- Talent and Other carry handling fees. The talent, talent expenses and Other sections end with a handling fee line, which is separate from the production fee.
- Contingency has its own block. The summary page has a “Contingencies (Not Billed)” area, which keeps contingency visible instead of buried in the lines.
The job information block also matters. It asks for pre-production days, build and strike days, pre-light, stage days, location days, locations, and spot titles and lengths, and it names the editorial, VFX and music companies. Those few fields are the plan the numbers below them price.
How the price is built: firm bid, cost-plus and the production fee
The buying method decides what the bottom line means. The AICP Bidding Reference Guide (February 2026) lists it among the first-call questions: “Is this project firm bid, cost-plus, or a blend?”
Firm bid
Under a firm bid, the AICP live-action guidelines say, the accepted proposal “becomes the contract price for the job, barring any change in specifications.” They add that there are “no accounting obligations” to the client for actual costs after the production.
For you, that means the total is the price, and savings or overruns inside the agreed scope sit with the producer. It also means the scope has to be written precisely, because anything outside it becomes a change order.
Cost-plus-fixed-fee
The guidelines describe cost-plus-fixed-fee as a method “designed for projects where there are a number of unknown factors”. The producer estimates costs, adds a fixed dollar fee, and after the job bills “all actual direct costs plus the agreed upon fixed fee.”
The guidelines are direct about the risk: actual costs may come in higher, “and accordingly, there should be no ‘Not to Exceed’ expectation” on the client’s side. Costs that greatly exceed the estimate should be approved before they are incurred, and an audit, if wanted, is at the client’s expense within one year of the end of photography.
The production fee
The production fee is the producer’s margin and overhead. The AICP guidelines say it is “normally the result of simple multiplication” of a markup percentage and the A to K costs, and that it represents the company’s “administrative and sales costs as well as a fee for its services provided from prep through wrap.”
The same text notes two variations you will see. Some producers quote a lump-sum, all-inclusive production fee, especially on low-budget jobs. Others add a creative fee when they do concept or script work outside the traditional scope of production.
The AICP stresses that fee percentages and bid terms are each company’s independent decision. So do not compare percentages across bids in isolation. Compare the fee in dollars, and check which lines it is applied to.
| Buying method | What the total means | Who carries cost risk inside the scope | What to ask for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Firm bid | The contract price for the agreed specifications | The producer | A precise scope, exclusions and the change order process |
| Cost-plus-fixed-fee | A forecast; actual costs plus a fixed fee are billed | The client | Approval thresholds, reporting dates and audit terms |
| Blend | Some lines fixed, some actualized | Split, line by line | A clear list of which lines are actualized |
Reading the estimate section by section
Read the job information block first, then the summary, then the detail pages. The summary tells you where the money sits; the detail pages tell you why.
Crew and days
Count the days before you look at rates. A one-day shoot with two prep days and a wrap day is a different job from a one-day shoot with five prep days, and the A section shows which one was priced.
Then match crew roles to the shot list. A tabletop product shot, a drone plate and a dialogue scene need different departments. If a role you expect is missing, ask whether it is covered by someone else or simply not planned.
Locations, permits and art
Location costs scale with the number of places and the moves between them. Permits come with lead times and insurance requirements set by each jurisdiction, so a date that is too close can force a costlier location. In Colorado Springs, for example, city park filming needs a permit applied for 14 days ahead and a certificate of insurance, according to the Visit Colorado Springs film permits page.
For art, check whether build and strike days are priced on the studio page and whether the set is built or rented. A set built for a two-day shoot carries its build days whether or not you see them on the call sheet.
Equipment and media
Equipment follows the shoot days and the camera package. Media covers drives, data handling, transcoding and dailies.
The AICP reference guide flags a common gap: whether editorial needs transcoded footage the night after the shoot, and whether the source drive goes to more than one vendor. Both add cost to the production bid if they are not already there.
Director and talent
The director’s fee is its own section, split into prep, travel, shoot and post days. If the director is expected in the edit, look for post days.
Talent is where a bid most often looks cheaper than it is. The talent section can price only session fees, leaving usage for later, or it can include the usage your media plan needs. Ask which. Our article on talent usage, holding fees and buyouts explains why that line can grow after the shoot.
Insurance and the bottom of the page
The live-action guidelines treat the production company as the preferred buyer of production insurance and list the usual coverages, from the production package and general liability to workers’ compensation and errors and omissions. The reference guide asks whether the job will be covered by the advertiser’s wrap-up insurance instead. Check that the bid says which, because two bids that differ only on this line are not pricing the same risk.
Where mixed-media jobs fall outside the form
The AICP Bid Form was built around live-action production. A spot that mixes filmed shots with 2D animation, 3D renders and AI-assisted steps has costs the lettered sections do not name, and different producers park them in different places.
3D models, look development and render time
A 3D shot needs a model before it needs a render. If the client supplies clean CAD files, the model may be a short conversion; if not, it is a build. Look development (materials, lighting, finishes) and review rounds sit on top.
Render time is a real cost driver and it is arithmetic, not opinion. Frames per pass equal seconds times frame rate, and hours equal frames times minutes per frame divided by machines. The render time calculator does that sum, and a bid that schedules three passes is pricing three times the render hours of a bid that schedules one.
Animation seconds
2D animation is often priced by the second or by the shot. Ask what counts as an animated second. Drawn elements composited over live action are animation too, and a bid that counts only full-frame animation seconds will look smaller.
The choice of medium for each shot moves more money than any rate. Our guide to choosing between animation, live action or both works through that decision shot by shot.
AI-assisted steps and tool terms
AI-assisted steps, such as rotoscoping a matte or removing an object from a plate, are usually priced as artist time plus any tool cost. The pricing is less important than the terms around it.
The AICP’s guidelines for generative AI in production and post-production agreements (checked November 2026) recommend that the agreement set out the use and purpose of generative AI and any prohibited uses. They suggest platforms that offer commercial terms with intellectual property indemnity, do not train on inputs or outputs, and permit the advertiser to use the output without restriction. They also suggest contract language acknowledging that material created by generative AI “may not, in whole or in part, be subject to copyright or other intellectual property protections.” Ask each bidder which steps are AI-assisted and under which tool terms, and expect that answer in writing.
Versions, captions and delivery
Each extra length, aspect ratio, language and offer is a version, and each version takes edit time and a quality check. The count multiplies quickly: 3 lengths x 4 ratios x 2 languages x 1 call to action is 24 deliverables. The versioning matrix calculator turns that matrix into a count and hours.
Captions, subtitle files, loudness measurement and delivery to each platform belong in the same place. If one bid includes them and another lists “deliverables per agency spec,” you are comparing a finished campaign with a hero master.
Lines to request as breakouts
The P sections of the form exist for exactly this: additional estimates broken out as expenses, labor and talent. Asking every bidder to use the same breakout lines for mixed-media work makes those costs comparable.
| Breakout line | Unit to ask for | Why it varies between bids |
|---|---|---|
| 3D model build or CAD conversion | Per model | Clean CAD versus building from drawings or photos |
| Look development | Per product or finish | Number of materials, colors and review rounds |
| 3D shots | Per shot, with seconds | Shot length, camera moves and complexity |
| Render passes | Passes x frames | One final pass versus test and revision passes |
| 2D animation | Per second, with what counts as a second | Full-frame animation versus elements over live action |
| Compositing | Per shot | Number of layers: plate, 3D, drawn elements, mattes |
| AI-assisted steps | Per step, with artist review time | Which steps, which tools and terms, who reviews |
| Versions | Per deliverable | Lengths x ratios x languages x calls to action |
| Captions and subtitles | Per language | File formats and burned-in versus sidecar |
| Quality check and delivery | Per destination | Number of platforms and their specs |
A bidder may still prefer its own structure. Ask for its numbers to be mapped onto these lines as well, so you are not left to guess where a cost went.
Post-production and music
The PDF form names the editorial, VFX and music companies in the job information block but has no lettered section for editorial and finishing. The AICP reference guide asks whether a job is bid “through delivery of the spot (instead of footage delivered to editorial)”. So check whether post is inside the bid, in the P breakouts, or on a separate estimate from another company.
Music is the same. The reference guide asks whether the proposed budget is “all in” and whether it includes “post, talent, VFX, music, finish”. A bid that excludes music has not priced a license, and our article on music licensing for ads shows how wide that line can be.
The assumptions page: exclusions, weather days, overages and cancellation
Every serious estimate ends with assumptions and exclusions. Read them before the numbers, because they decide what the numbers mean.
Exclusions
Look for these phrases and put a value or a question next to each:
- “Client to provide” (product samples, CAD files, footage, fonts, music).
- “Usage per talent agreement” or “usage TBD”.
- “Deliverables per spec” without a list.
- “Post by others” or “footage delivered to editorial”.
- “Stock and licensed materials not included”. The AICP reference guide asks about stock costs directly.
- “Rates subject to change”. In May 2025 the AICP published sample bid language on tariffs, including a clause under which a US production company “shall not be responsible for price increases incurred after the award of the bid due to tariffs.” Clauses like this move cost risk to you.
Weather and contingency days
The AICP live-action guidelines define a contingency day as one where a scheduled shoot is prevented “due to circumstances beyond the control of the production company”, such as weather, the absence of client-supplied elements like key talent or color-correct product, or force majeure. They set out what such a day costs under the guidelines: out-of-pocket costs, a share of the director’s fee that depends on how late the postponement is, and “a service charge of no less than 15% of all direct costs.”
Ask each bidder for its weather day cost per day. The guidelines say that, if requested and practicable, the producer will quote “an estimated exposure figure” as a cost per day. For outdoor work in the mountains, that one line can matter more than the difference between two totals.
Overages and change orders
The guidelines define an overage as a cost “incurred when there is a change in the project specifications”, billed as a change order. Major changes, such as an added shoot day, increase the contract price, and the guidelines show 75% of such an overage due on execution. The production fee applies to overages at the same percentage as the awarded bid.
The practical rule is simple. Name one person on your side who may approve changes, and get every change priced before the work starts. The guidelines say overages “should be negotiated and executed prior to the commencement of the work.”
Cancellation and payment
The guidelines’ cancellation terms depend on notice. With notice during or within one to ten business days before the job, the producer is owed costs incurred or committed and the full production fee as bid. With more than ten business days’ notice, the fee share falls to not less than 50%.
They also describe a “75-25” payment plan, with 75% of the contract price due at signing and no later than five business days before the first shoot day, and 25% after dailies are approved. The AICP shows these figures as examples and says each company sets its own terms. Read the payment schedule in each bid, because two bids with equal totals and different payment terms carry different cash and risk.
From estimate to final invoice
What happens after the shoot depends on the buying method. Under a firm bid, the final payment is the balance of the contract price plus approved overages; no cost report is owed. Under cost-plus, the producer actualizes: it reports actual direct costs, adds the fixed fee, and bills the difference from what was paid.
For a blended job, the AICP guidelines keep the two parts apart. The firm bid portion of the final payment follows the agreed schedule “and shall not be delayed due to the actualization of the cost plus items,” while invoices for cost-plus items are due on receipt and payable within 30 days. If your accounts team expects one final invoice, say so before award.
Ask, too, when the estimate expires. Crew rates, equipment availability and stage holds change, and a bid accepted months after it was written may no longer reflect the producer’s costs. A firm bid with a validity date protects both sides.
Red flags on an estimate page
Some patterns on an estimate deserve a question even before you compare it with another bid:
- Round-number allowances for large items (“post allowance $10,000”) with no days, rates or deliverables behind them.
- One line for all of post, with no split between editorial, color, sound, graphics and versions.
- No prep days for department heads on a job with builds, props or product preparation.
- Usage written as “TBD” for talent or music, which leaves the largest variable cost off the page.
- Contingency spread across lines instead of shown separately, which makes the production fee and the true costs impossible to read.
- No insurance line and no mention of the advertiser’s wrap-up program.
- Deliverables described as “per spec” with no count.
- A state incentive netted into the total. If a bid assumes a rebate or credit, ask for it as a separate line with its conditions. Our article on the Colorado film incentive explains the conditions and the state office’s review behind any incentive.
None of these is proof of a bad bid. Each is a place where the bid’s plan is not yet visible, which is what you need before you can compare it.
Who is liable for what: the terms behind the numbers
Two contract points sit behind every estimate and are easy to miss when the bid comes through an agency. The AICP live-action guidelines say that when an agency contracts on behalf of a disclosed advertiser, the advertiser “is legally bound to all terms and conditions agreed to by its agent.” They also describe sequential liability clauses, under which the advertiser pays first and the agency pays once it has received the funds. Your counsel decides what your agency agreement says; the point for estimate readers is to know whose signature commits the money.
AI-assisted work adds its own allocation of risk. The AICP’s generative AI guidelines suggest that the producer warrant a “commercially reasonable human review” of outputs, with final clearance of AI-generated material resting with the agency or advertiser. They also suggest the advertiser indemnify the producer for prompts and content it supplies, for disclosure requirements, and for the use of talent likenesses in AI tools. If a bid prices AI-assisted steps, read the terms that come with it, because they decide who answers a claim later.
How to compare two bids fairly
A fair comparison holds the plan constant and lets only the producers’ choices vary. Five steps get you there.
- Separate contingency and fees. Move any contingency out of both bids into a single line, and note each production fee in dollars and the lines it covers.
- Match the deliverable matrix. List lengths, ratios, languages and versions for each bid. Ask the bidder with the shorter list to price the missing deliverables.
- Match usage. Talent and music must cover the same media, territory and term in both bids. Ask for usage as its own line in each.
- Fill the exclusions. Price each “client to provide” or “by others” item, either from the other bid or from a quote you hold, and add it to the bid that left it out.
- Compare what is left, line by line. The remaining gap is the real difference in how the two producers would make the spot. Ask about the biggest lines first.
The AICP’s 2026 bidding best practices add the fairness rules that make this possible: supply all bidders with the same job-scope information, and keep each bidder’s creative ideas and costs confidential. The same document warns against asking for “check bids” and against sharing one bidder’s numbers with another. Normalizing is something you do on your side, with your own spreadsheet.
Example (fictional). Two invented production companies bid the fictional Orlenna Ridge Bottle hero spot: 30 seconds, one shoot day, 14 seconds with drawn elements, three 3D shots, and a plan for 24 deliverables (3 lengths x 4 ratios x 2 languages x 1 call to action). Every figure is an illustration, not a Blendpipe price and not a market rate.
Bid A totals $50,880 with no contingency: development $6,800; shoot costs $12,900; production fee $2,580 (20% of $12,900); director $2,500; talent $1,800 (one on-camera performer, organic social and the website only, 12 months); 2D animation $5,600; 3D $10,400; post $7,600 including 3 deliverables (30, 15 and 6 seconds, 16:9, English); insurance $700. Music and voiceover are excluded.
Bid B totals $69,619: development $7,200; shoot costs $13,000; production fee $1,950 (15% of $13,000); director $3,000; talent $2,400 (same performer, paid social and online video, 12 months); 2D animation $6,300; 3D $12,000; post $8,400; 23 extra versions at $180 = $4,140; music allowance $2,500; voiceover $1,500; insurance $900. That subtotal is $63,290, plus 10% contingency of $6,329.
The apparent gap is $69,619 minus $50,880 = $18,739. Normalizing it:
| Step | Adjustment | Gap after the step |
|---|---|---|
| Start | B minus A as submitted | $18,739 |
| 1 | Take B’s contingency out ($6,329) | $12,410 |
| 2 | A quotes the 21 missing versions at $190 each = $3,990 | $8,420 |
| 3 | A adds the same music allowance, $2,500 | $5,920 |
| 4 | A quotes voiceover at $1,400 | $4,520 |
| 5 | A quotes the paid-social talent usage, plus $700 | $3,820 |
Normalized, A is $59,470 and B is $63,290 before contingency: 63,290 minus 59,470 = $3,820. The remaining difference, line by line (B minus A): 3D +$1,600; post +$800; 2D animation +$700; director +$500; development +$400; insurance +$200; versions +$150; shoot +$100; voiceover +$100; talent minus $100; production fee minus $630. Those add up to $3,820.
The next question writes itself: why is B’s 3D $1,600 higher? Here, B priced a model built from the product drawings with two review rounds, while A assumed the client would supply a clean model. That is a plan difference to settle, not a price difference to negotiate. With the same 10% contingency on both, the gap is $3,820 x 1.10 = $4,202.
Questions to ask each bidder before you award
Normalizing leaves a short list of real differences. These questions turn each one into a decision you can make.
About the plan
- How many shoot days, prep days and build days does this price, and what happens if the shot list grows by one setup?
- Which shots are filmed, animated, rendered or AI-assisted, and why?
- How many review rounds are included at each stage (boards, animatic, style frames, offline edit, online)?
About the money
- Is this a firm bid, cost-plus or a blend, and which lines would be actualized?
- Which sections does the production fee apply to, and is there a creative fee?
- What is the weather day exposure per day, and what triggers it?
- What is the payment schedule?
About rights and paperwork
- Which talent usage is priced, for which media, territory and term?
- Is music licensed, allowed for or excluded? If licensed, for how long and where?
- Which AI tools would be used, under which terms, and what records will we receive?
- Who owns the project files, 3D models and raw footage at delivery? Our article on who owns commercial footage covers that question in depth.
Ask for the answers in writing, attached to the estimate. A bid’s assumptions page is part of the contract you are about to sign.
A short glossary for estimate readers
These terms appear on most commercial estimates. Each definition is short enough to keep beside the bid.
- Firm bid. A fixed contract price for a defined scope; changes in specifications become change orders.
- Cost-plus-fixed-fee. Actual direct costs billed after the job, plus a fixed dollar fee agreed in advance.
- Production fee. The producer’s overhead and margin, usually a percentage of sections A to K or a lump sum.
- Fringes. Payroll taxes and benefits added to labor lines.
- Handling fee. A fee on pass-through sections such as talent and Other, separate from the production fee.
- Contingency. Money set aside for risk inside the agreed scope; the AICP form shows it as not billed unless used.
- Overage. A cost caused by a change in specifications, approved before the work and billed as a change order.
- Weather day. A shoot day lost to conditions beyond the producer’s control, priced by the terms in the bid.
- Wrap-up insurance. An insurance program provided by the agency or advertiser in place of the producer’s own production package.
- Usage. The media, territory and term for which talent and music are paid; it is often priced separately from the session.
The production glossary has the wider vocabulary of animation, 3D, live action, post and rights.
What to do next with the estimates in front of you
Start with the plan, not the total. Write down the deliverable matrix, the usage and the buying method you actually need, then run each bid through the five steps above.
A practical order of work:
- Put both bids into the production budget worksheet, one column each, using the same rows. The worksheet’s example rows (development, live action, animation, 3D, post, talent, rights and versions) are a usable default.
- Rebuild the plan with your own rates in the video budget calculator. Its default values (for example, $13,500 of live action for one illustrative shoot day and a $48,884 total) are illustrations only; replace each with a figure you hold.
- List every exclusion and ask each bidder to price it, or price it yourself.
- Ask the questions above, in writing, and attach the answers to the estimate.
- Award on the like-for-like gap and the plan you prefer, not on the first page.
If you are deciding what kind of engagement to buy at all, a single spot, a launch campaign or a versioning job, the engagement types page explains what changes in the plan for each. Blendpipe is a production studio in Colorado Springs that combines live action, animation, 3D and AI-assisted tools, and every production plan it returns includes a line-item estimate with its assumptions and contingency stated. To get one for your own project, send a brief.
